"Just look at last year's Western Conference Semifinals. In the four losses to Dallas, Rantanen had just two points and was a -7 in his time on the ice. Despite being one of the biggest players on the ice, he was constantly losing puck battles along the boards and not doing much in the defensive zone to help his team win." -Finnegan
Although
Nathan MacKinnon may struggle defensively at times, he consistently delivers offensively in crucial games, making his $12.6 million AAV contract worthwhile for the Avalanche. There's a clear reason why MacFarland and the front office were hesitant to offer Moose the same payday as MacKinnon, and Rantanen's recent nine-game slump has only validated their decision, writes Finnegan.
"If you're going to have two players be among the top-five highest paid guys in the league, you need both of them to show up when all the chips are shoved to the middle, not just one. While no one will ever know what Rantanen would've done with a new contract in Colorado, his performance for Dallas in the Conference Finals is giving a hint at what the Avalanche could've seen from No. 96." -Finnegan